Prop Firm News Trading Rules, Compared Before You Buy the Challenge
Tomorrow at 8:30 AM Eastern the October jobs report prints, and what you are allowed to do about it depends entirely on which firm holds your account and which phase it is in. MyFundedFutures wants you flat two minutes either side. FundingPips zeroes out the profit of anything you open near the release. FundingPips Zero closes the account outright. The trades are identical; the rules are three different worlds, and the phase matters as much as the firm: FTMO hands you news freedom in the challenge and takes half of it back the day you pass.
Key Takeaways
- The window rules run on three tiers. Flatten and stay flat (MyFundedFutures: nothing open from 2 minutes before to 2 minutes after), keep the account but lose the profit (FundingPips Master, FundedNext Stellar funded, MyFundedFX: profits deducted, no violation), or lose the account (FundingPips Zero: any open, close or hold inside the window terminates it).
- The phase changes the rule more than the firm does. FTMO allows news trading through both challenge phases on every account type, then restricts funded Standard accounts to 2 minutes either side and strips profit from window trades. FundedNext Stellar funds with a 40% profit haircut on window trades. MyFundedFutures permits Tier 1 news on every evaluation and bans it on Rapid and Pro funded accounts.
- The hold-out rule is the one worth planning around. FundingPips excludes trades opened 5 or more hours before a release: hold long enough and your close inside the window still counts. FundedNext pays 40% of window-trade profits while losses count 100%.
- The gap between phases costs real money on NFP. Gold fell $40.65 on Friday October 23, from $4,048.55 down to a $3,975 low, its weakest since July 20. A 2-minute flat window on a funded account would have kept you out of the 8:30 spike entirely; a 10-minute Zero window bans you from the whole first move.
- NFP lands tomorrow, Friday November 6 at 8:30 AM ET (6:00 PM IST). Consensus is +65K against September's +29K, per the Forex Factory calendar. Check your firm's dashboard calendar tonight, because several firms name their own calendar as the only official list of restricted releases.
Why Firms Block News at All
Strip away the marketing and every news rule exists for one of two reasons. The first is honest: around a red-folder release, spreads widen, liquidity pulls, and fills get ugly. Our FTMO slippage piece documents a stop that filled 90 pips past its level on a news spike. A trader who was flat anyway never experienced that fill. The second reason firms say out loud less often: simulated feeds do not reproduce real news fills. MyFundedFutures states it directly in its news policy, that news trading is "not simulated 1:1 with live markets," which is the entire justification for banning it on funded accounts. A news scalper on a simulated feed can post fills no real broker would give, so the firm blocks the strategy that would not survive contact with the real thing.
Both reasons are real, but they produce different rules. The first justifies keeping you flat for a couple of minutes. The second justifies taking your money. Most firms do both, at different phases, which is why the same trade can be legal on Tuesday and a payout-deduction on Thursday.
The Three Tiers, and the Phase That Changes Them
Every news rule in this space fits one of three shapes, and it pays to know which one your account wears before you size a position.
| Tier | What happens in the window | Who runs it | What it means for a $10K account |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat window | No positions or orders may be open from 2 minutes before to 2 minutes after the release | MyFundedFutures (Rapid, Rapid EOD, Pro, Tier 1 events), FTMO funded Standard (2 min either side on selected releases) | You sit out 4 minutes. Missing the first candle is the entire cost. |
| Profit deduction | Account survives; profits from trades opened or closed inside the window are removed | FundingPips Master, FundedNext Stellar funded (40% of profit kept), MyFundedFX (profits inside the window stripped) | A $2,000 news winner can pay $800 or nothing. Losses still count at 100%. |
| Termination | Opening, closing or holding inside the window ends the account | FundingPips Zero (10 minutes either side, hard breach) | One impatient click on a red folder is the account. |
The table's middle row is where traders lose the most money, because it does not feel like a rule. Nothing happens when you breach it. The trade fills, the stop runs, the profit prints on the dashboard. Then payout day arrives and the profit is not there, or only 40% of it is. FundedNext's funded Stellar terms say it plainly: only 40 percent of the profit from trades opened or closed inside the restricted window counts at payout, losses count 100 percent, and partial closes taint the whole order. That is an asymmetric bet wearing a rulebook.
Firm by Firm: The Actual Windows
The details below come from each firm's published policy pages, checked this week. Firms revise these tables without much ceremony, FundedNext banned weekend holding in January and restored it in May, so treat your dashboard as the live source and this as the map.
| Firm and phase | News rule | Detail that decides payouts |
|---|---|---|
| MyFundedFutures, all evaluations | Tier 1 trading allowed | Straddles and strangles banned on every account, every release |
| MyFundedFutures, Rapid / Rapid EOD / Pro funded | Nothing open 2 min before to 2 min after Tier 1 releases (FOMC, Employment Report, CPI, plus EIA and ag reports for those markets) | Their example: an 8:30 release means flat by 8:28:00, reopen after 8:32:00. Limit orders count as open positions. |
| MyFundedFutures, Builder plan funded | Tier 1 trading allowed | The 2-minute no-open-positions protocol still applies to all releases |
| FTMO Challenge / Verification, any account type | No news restriction | Slippage still applies; policy does not |
| FTMO Account (funded), Standard | Executions, stops, targets and pendings restricted 2 min either side of selected releases | Holding is allowed if the position opened more than 2 minutes before the event; violation may terminate |
| FTMO Account (funded), Swing | No news restriction, leverage drops from 1:100 to 1:30 | The trade is flexibility for leverage |
| FundedNext Challenge (Stellar) | News trading allowed | None. The restriction starts at funding |
| FundedNext funded (Stellar) | Restricted window 5 min either side of listed high-impact events | 40% of window-trade profit counts at payout; losses count fully; partial closes taint the order |
| FundingPips evaluation (1 Step Flex / 2 Step) | No holding restrictions during releases | Purposely trading news is prohibited in both stages and closes the account |
| FundingPips Master | Restricted window around high-impact releases and speeches; holding through is allowed | Trades opened 5+ hours before the event are excluded and count fully (the 5-hour rule) |
| FundingPips Zero | Opening, closing or holding inside 10 min either side of restricted releases | Hard breach, account closed, no soft tier |
Two things in that table deserve a second read. First, the MyFundedFutures phase flip: three of its four plans let you trade CPI and FOMC through the evaluation and ban it the day you are funded, so a track record built partly on news days describes a strategy you are no longer allowed to run. Second, the FundingPips evaluation footnote, "purposely trading news is prohibited" in both stages, sits one line under the promise of no holding restrictions. Holding through a release because you were already in a swing position is fine. Entering because a number is about to print is not, and your firm is the referee.
The 5-Hour Hold-Out
Most windows treat every trade the same regardless of when it opened, which is what makes swing traders furious: position from Tuesday, release at 8:30 Friday, profit deducted anyway. FundingPips built the exception worth copying. Trades opened 5 or more hours before a high-impact event are excluded from the restriction entirely, can be closed inside the window, and their profits count in full. FundedNext has no equivalent; its answer is the 40% haircut, which is at least honest about keeping some of your money.
The practical version of this rule is a planning habit, and you can run it on any firm. Before you hold anything into a red folder, write down when you opened it. If your firm runs a hold-out rule, check your entry time against it before you check your P&L. If it does not, the decision is starker: close before the window, or accept that whatever the release pays you may be confiscated at payout. Friday is a live demo. NFP at 8:30 AM Eastern against a +65K consensus will move gold, the dollar and the indices in the same four minutes no matter what your account type says.
What It Costs You on NFP Friday
Numbers make the tiers concrete, so here is Friday's setup priced. Gold spent the last week sliding from about $4,115 to a $3,975 low on Friday October 23, the weakest print since July 20, closing that day down $40.65 at $4,007.90 on the December futures. It has since stabilized and trades near $4,115 again as of Thursday evening. A standard gold lot is 100 ounces, so that Friday slide was worth $4,065 per lot end to end, and the 8:30 release candle on jobs days regularly carries a $30-80 range, $3,000-8,000 per lot. Now the tiers:
- Flat window (MFFU funded Rapid or Pro): you are flat by 8:28 and the first candle belongs to someone else. Your cost is the move you were not allowed to trade, which on a median jobs release is roughly $1,450 in the first five minutes, $3,870 across the first hour, per the release medians we tracked in the NFP preview.
- Profit deduction (FundedNext funded): you can trade the print, and if you catch a $4,000 winner, $1,600 survives to payout while a $4,000 loser counts in full. Trade the window ten times at 50% accuracy and the arithmetic grinds you down no matter how good your read is.
- Termination (FundingPips Zero): the 10-minute window covers the entire spike and most of the first move. There is no version of Friday where trading it is worth an account.
- Hold-out (FundingPips Master, 5-hour rule): entered Wednesday afternoon or earlier, your Thursday-and-Friday gold short is legitimate through the release, profit intact. That single entry-time decision is worth more than any calendar annotation you will make this quarter.
One more cost that never shows in the rules table: the orange folder. FundingPips restricts speeches alongside high-impact releases, and medium-impact events like Friday's UoM consumer sentiment at 10:00 AM Eastern carry lighter rules at some firms and none at others. If your strategy trades pullbacks into London and New York opens, check where your firm's calendar actually draws the line, because the day has more than one folder on it.
Choosing a Firm That Fits Your Calendar
Reverse the usual order. Most traders pick a firm on price and target, then discover the calendar. Do it the other way: write down the releases your strategy actually trades, then find the firm whose funded-phase rule tolerates them.
- If your edge is the news spike itself, your funded options are FTMO Swing (leverage 1:30), FundedNext Stellar (40% of profits on window trades), MyFundedFutures Builder, or FundingPips Master with every entry logged 5 hours ahead of the print. Those are the only funded configurations in this piece where the strategy survives.
- If you trade news days as volatility but your entries come hours before, the flat windows cost you little. Keep the position diary anyway, because entry timestamps are the evidence that your trade was a hold, not a scalp.
- If you hold multi-day swings through data, check weekend rules while you are at it. They are cousins of the same risk family: FundedNext reinstated weekend holding on May 8 after banning it in January, FundingPips auto-closes Master positions outside a Swing add-on, and FTMO exempts Swing accounts from the close-before-weekend rule while requiring it of funded Standard.
- Whatever you pick, read the funded-phase page, not the challenge page. The challenge page is the advertisement. The funded page is the contract.
Prove your entries before the firm asks
Every rule in this piece turns on timestamps: when you opened, when you closed, which calendar your firm uses. ChartWise journals each trade with its entry time against the economic calendar, so when a payout review questions a window trade, your answer is a log, not a memory. The traders who win these disputes are the ones who wrote it down at the time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are red folder news events?
Red folder events are the high-impact releases on the Forex Factory calendar: NFP, CPI, FOMC and rate decisions. The name comes from the red impact icon. Firms treat them as the windows where spreads widen, fills slip and quotes gap, which is why the rules concentrate there. Medium-impact orange-folder releases carry separate, lighter rules at some firms.
Can you trade news on a prop firm challenge?
Usually yes during the evaluation, and that is exactly the trap. FTMO allows news trading through both challenge phases on every account type, FundedNext allows it in the challenge phase, MyFundedFutures permits Tier 1 trading on every evaluation, and FundingPips evaluation stages have no news holding restrictions. The restriction lands when the account starts paying out.
Why do news rules change after you pass?
Because the firm carries the payout once you are funded. The standard explanation is that news fills are not simulated one-to-one with live markets, so a news fill on a funded account can look better than anything the real broker would have given. That is MyFundedFutures' stated reason, and it is also why the payout restrictions are the strictest tier across every firm in this piece.
Which prop firms allow news trading on funded accounts?
On funded accounts the fully open tier is nearly empty. FTMO Swing allows it with reduced leverage, FundedNext Stellar funded keeps it but pays only 40% of window-trade profits at payout, MyFundedFutures Builder plans allow Tier 1 news on the funded account, and FundingPips Master allows holding through releases under the 5-hour rule while banning deliberate news trading. Everything else narrows to windows, profit deductions or flat prohibitions.
The Short Version
- Three tiers, one release: flat window (MFFU Rapid/Pro funded, FTMO funded Standard, 2 minutes either side), profit deduction (FundedNext funded 40/100, FundingPips Master, MyFundedFX), termination (FundingPips Zero, 10 minutes)
- The challenge phase is the advertisement; the funded phase is the contract. MFFU evaluations allow Tier 1 news, MFFU Rapid and Pro funded accounts ban it. FTMO challenges are unrestricted, funded Standard is not
- FundingPips' 5-hour rule is the swing trader's exception: opened 5+ hours before the release, the close inside the window counts in full
- Friday's NFP (Nov 6, 8:30 AM ET, +65K expected against 29K) is a live test: gold's median first-hour range on jobs days is about $38.7, or $3,870 per lot
- Check the firm's own dashboard calendar tonight; several firms name it the only official list of restricted releases

